Springers' '96 title all about pitching, new regime

Written for 2002 State Tournament Program 

By Tom Elliott
St. Cloud Times

It wasn’t articulated at the time. No one truly made a big deal about it. But winning the 1996 state Class B championship was a redemption of sorts for the Cold Spring Springers.

That’s because, for the first time since the 1955 state championship, amateur baseball Hall of Famer Bill Huls wasn’t a part of the Springers’ state title.

With the ‘96 title, Dave Hinkemeyer officially had an unspoken, although recognized, monkey off his back.

"After the fact, I think I heard about it," said Hinkemeyer, who views Huls as a mentor and a great manager. "I know heard some things in 1994, after that first year that I took over. We started out 8-8. I think people thought we were going to go in the tank."

Instead of going in the tank, Cold Spring won its fifth state championship. The Springers did it with two key additions -- Steve Taylor and Dave Oehrlein. Both were returning to amateur ball after playing professionally. Taylor had reached Class A ball as a pitcher in the Minnesota Twins organization. Oehrlein, a left-hander and former St. Cloud State star, reached Class AA with the St. Louis Cardinals before getting his release.

"The thing about that year, in my mind, was our 1-2 punch of Todd Steil and Dave Oehrlein," Hinkemeyer said. "They were our top two pitchers and they were just incredible. It seemed like every game they pitched was either a shutout or one-run game."

Cold Spring opened the 16-team, double-elimination tournament in Glencoe and Brownton with a 3-2 win over Shakopee. Then, it beat New Ulm 10-0.

In the quarterfinals at Brownton, the Springers beat the Miesville Mudhens 5-3. Matt Butala and Josh Loesh hit homers. Steil, a right-hander and St. Cloud State star, got the pitching win to improve to 9-3.

In the semifinals, the Springers beat the Dundas Dukes 1-0. Oehrlein tossed a two-hitter to out-duel the Dukes’ Dana Kiecker, a former Boston Red Sox pitcher who, like Oehrlein, had starred at St. Cloud State.

The Springers only run came on a home run by Matt Butala, who was having one of his best years as a Springer, batting .410 with 14 home runs and 45 RBI.

In the championship, Cold Spring beat the Dukes, who had come through the losers’ bracket, 6-4. A draftee from St. Cloud O’Hara’s, Rob Mettenburg, got the pitching win. Butala started on the mound. Butala and Taylor each had two hits.

Taylor, who played baseball at Florida Atlantic University, was named the tournament MVP. He hit .529 (9-for-17) and had 25 chances at second base with no errors. The final day’s attendance was 2,270.

"What I remember is that Matt’s father had passed away earlier in the season," Hinkemeyer said. "Now you know how Matt is. He’s not sentimental at all. But he told me after that home run, ‘I can’t explain it. But that home run was my dad. It was my dad.’"

The club, which finished 36-6, was solid.

Rod Schafer was the catcher. Butala played first. Taylor was at second and Ron Terres was at shortstop. Pat Dolan, a Florida Atlantic teammate of Taylor’s, played third base, as did Jeff Lindbloom.

The outfield featured Loesch, a St. Cloud State star, Billy Theis and Troy Stein, who was starting for the University of Minnesota. Dwight Kotila also played in the outfield. Not playing was Ben Griffin, who was out with a back injury.

But what was special about the ’Springers was their pitching. Steil was 9-3 with a 2.34 ERA. Taylor was 8-1 with a 2.76 ERA. Oehrlein was 7-0 with a 1.50 ERA. Butala was 5-0 with a 1.80 ERA. And Hinkemeyer, the manager, was 4-1 with a 2.38 ERA.

"We had a lot of depth," Hinkemeyer said.

And, they had finally won a state title without Huls, a baseball icon in Cold Spring and Central Minnesota.

"My personality and Bill Huls’ personalities are completely opposite," Hinkemeyer said. "People took advantage of that at first. They did some things to me that they never would have done to Bill.

"My approach is a lot more relaxed. I don’t feel like I’m adding any pressure to the situation. For our players, they bring on all the pressure they need themselves.

"Bill was a great manager and the way he did things was right for him. Obviously, he had a lot of success with it. If Bill was still manager, he’d be very successful and people would play for him. I’ve done OK. But we have done well not because of me or any individual. Anyone could manage the Springers and do very well."